Recommendations —
English
 

Election Observation Portal - Recommendations Database

Country

Year

Topic

Organization

Recommendation status


Keywords (full text search)




3752 recommendations
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 8 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The legal value of party agents' signature of the results forms should be clarified, taking into accounts the consequences on both the validity of these results and the possibility for political parties to reject them later in the process


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 1 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The NEC should ensure that political parties are provided with copies of protocols at all stages of the voting and counting process. Some of the problems witnessed in these
elections stem from the fact that voting and counting took place on different dates, which if the Election Law is not amended will not be the case in future elections. Nonetheless, providing stakeholders with documentation at each and every step is important for the transparency and the integrity of the process.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 2 (Voter registration) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The introduction of a permanent voter register is a major improvement. The NEC and the Commune Councils must ensure that the register is properly updated every year. The
NEC and commune councils should strengthen voter education before and during the annual updating of the register in order to enable as many eligible voters as possible to
register.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 3 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The NEC should be given authority to issue regulations and instructions pertaining to all aspects of voter registration, including certification of residency. On this particular issue, the Ministry of Interior could formally delegate to the NEC the power to regulate the process of certification of residence by Commune Chiefs during the registration period. This could prevent problems such as these encountered by a number of Buddhist monks during the registration for the 2003 elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 4 (Voter registration) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The NEC and Commune Councils should make sure that registered voters are provided with photo IDs required for voting. Although more expensive, Polaroid cameras could be
used


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 5 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The criteria for the appointment of PECs and CECs should be reconsidered. Observers and opposition parties have questioned the independence of the members of the Election Administration. Appointing experienced persons is justified, but without jeopardizing the performance of the election administration, the employment of qualified candidates without prior election experience should be considered


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 6 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The role of Village Chiefs, their appointment, responsibilities and dismissal should be defined. Although Article 30 of the Law on Commune Administration foresees that the
Minister of Interior issues guidelines on the qualification required, such guidelines have yet to be issued.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Election Administration, paragraph 7 (Complaints and Appeals) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

To improve the filing of complaints and to avoid their rejection on formal grounds, parties should enhance competences of their agents with a thorough training.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 1 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

Though the NEC Regulations have enhanced political parties' access to the media, a longterm process is necessary to create a culture of pluralism that would lead to an
environment favourable to the conduct of democratic elections. Therefore the general environment of the media should be strengthened.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 2 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

"The principles introduces by the UNDP-sponsored ""Equity ""programmes were considered as groundbreaking and important, and should be further developed beyond the election campaign period to introduce an ethic of pluralism in the treatment of news. The idea that the state media should follow objective journalistic criteria in the treatment of the news should be strengthened. Donors might wish to consider the funding of projects that would sustain a pluralistic access to the media."


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 3 (Media) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The state media still showed an imbalance in favour of the CPP in as much as many of the reported Government activities related almost entirely to the Prime Minister. To correct this situation a system should be envisaged in order to secure media coverage also for other parties of the ruling coalition as well as parliamentary parties not present in the government.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 4 (Media) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

In the absence of a law regulating the electronic media, NEC guidelines should clearly spell out that the broadcasting station is responsible for the material broadcast. The
regulations should also clarify, in case of infringement, the division of responsibilities between the NEC and the Ministry of Information as regards law enforcement and the
imposition of sanctions.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 5 (Media) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The imbalance in the private media goes back to the issue of granting broadcasting licences. These are mainly weighed in favour of CPP. At present the Ministry of
Information grants the licence after it is cleared by the Ministry of Communications. In order to make this system fairer and subject to public scrutiny, a Parliamentary
Committee for the Media could be established. Its advice would be required before granting the licences. Legislation would have to be enacted to this effect.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 1 (Voter registration) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

Establishing a centralized civil registry and a single national identity card (documento único de identidad). A single identity card by itself will not change the
current shortcomings of the padrón electoral, which basically stem from a municipally based inadequate civil registry and issuance of identity cards (cédulas
de vecindad).


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 2 (Voter registration) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

The above mentioned civil registry and citizen identity cards shall be the basis of permanent and more easily updated voter lists (padrón electoral).


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 3 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

Polling centers could be decentralized to smaller and more isolated locations than the municipal township in order to bring the ballot box closer to where the voters
live. This should be considered standard international practice. Moreover, it seemed that lower turnout at the second round in comparison to the first round, especially in the rural areas, had to do with a shortage of transportation made available by political parties and other social agents.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 4 (Legal Framework) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

Some institutional mechanisms for public information shall be created at the TSE in order for the electoral authorities to perform more transparently and responsively
before the party representatives and the citizens. According to widely shared democratic standards, this would include the following: a) making the law unambiguous in that the TSE shall hand out a copy of voter lists to Parties and Candidates enough in advance of elections day so that they can use voter lists for their political work., b) setting public information procedures at the TSE whereby political parties and citizens can be ensured that they have access to relevant
information on the handling of complaints related to voter and candidate registration as well as election results.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 5 (Legal Framework) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

An apparent legal vacuum on campaign funding, campaign expenses and financial control by public authorities should be filled in by appropriate legislation. The fact that this aspect of the electoral system is a highly controversial one everywhere should not preclude the establishing of certain limits, which could have some
positive effects as compared to situations where no limits existed at all. It is this Mission’s view that at least the opening of a public debate on this issue would be
beneficial to the cause of democracy in Guatemala.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 6 (Election Administration) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

The electoral calendar could be modified so that general elections are not held during the Christmas and crop season. Both factors are by themselves and for different reasons unfavorable to voter mobilization. The fact that the current electoral calendar is largely tied by constitutional provisions should not deter taking into consideration other alternatives on the timing for elections; including the possibility for a second round held before Christmas day without having to modify the current constitutional framework (i.e. from earlier in November until a week before Christmas if there is a second round). It goes without saying that this latter alternative does not write off the crop season obstacle.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 7 (Voter Education) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

Enhancing civic education especially among the peasants and indigenous populations. More than in previous occasions, indigenous people especially women
have shown to an extraordinary degree the political will to register, getting mobilized during the campaign and turn out on elections day. Certain areas of
citizen participation seem of particular importance such as the protection of fundamental rights and the procedures to deal with public authorities, both in getting
information and presenting complaints. On this latter respect, it is not just by change that the largest number of all electoral complaints brought before the electoral
authorities was discarded on the ground of the complainant’s “lack of active legitimacy.”


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 8 (Electoral System) Guatemala 2003
by: EU

In view of the potential for conflict around municipal elections, and the fact that current electoral law facilitates the election of mayors and the formation of governing majorities without the support of a majority of voters (such would be the case in one out of every four municipal councils), it seems advisable to open the public debate on the convenience of maintaining or changing the current formula of representation at municipal elections. The current formula allows for a party list obtaining a plurality to get the mayor and an absolute majority in the council. In a highly fragmented party system with stronger local than national bases, this formula discourages pre-electoral coalitions and post-electoral negotiation for governance; therefore encouraging the opposition to play municipal politics “from the street” rather than within the council. The current formula may have originally been designed to facilitate governance through easy formation of governing majorities, but as time passed the actual outcome may be working against the original purpose of the law. In connection with this issue, the EOM has elaborated relevant statistics based on the electoral results, which may be handed out to the TSE.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation The new electoral law, paragraph 1 (Legal Framework) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The new electoral law on Presidential and Parliamentary elections should be approved as soon as possible in order to facilitate its implementation in time for the coming elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation The new electoral law, paragraph 2 (Legal Framework) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The Mission would recommend the adoption of a general electoral law that could be used for every election with small “ad hoc” additional added updates (if required) for each particular electoral contest. In this new law electoral deadlines as a whole and namely those regarding the presentation of candidates and party lists, the assessment of candidatures, the issuing of the number of mandates and the final candidates list will currently have to be reassessed so that they are in line with the real standards and
conditions of the country.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation The new electoral law, paragraph 3 (Legal Framework) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

On the issue of disqualifications of candidates, it would be recommendable to include in the new electoral law an article in line with former Art. 152 of Law 3/99 on Presidential and National Assembly elections on publication of lists of candidates and verification of candidatures, that concedes the general public and candidates with eight days to complain against the preliminary published final lists of candidates.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation The new electoral law, paragraph 4 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The re-qualification of invalid votes should be done in a first instance at the intermediate level in order to facilitate the final results tabulation.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation The new electoral law, paragraph 5 (Legal Framework) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

In the new election law and in practice domestic and international election observers should be given full access to information that is relevant to the election process, in
particular to result tabulation at central level.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Professionalism of the electoral administration, paragraph 1 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Better and clearer channels of communication between CNE and STAE and between them and the other levels of administration of these institutions.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Professionalism of the electoral administration, paragraph 2 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Decentralization of decision making mechanisms in order to ease the electoral process in its different stages.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Professionalism of the electoral administration, paragraph 3 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

An administrative structure within CNE should be created to deal with complaints.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Professionalism of the electoral administration, paragraph 4 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

To improve the swiftness and visibility of the intermediate tabulation operations. For that aim, the Mission recommends: 1) to organize training for the staff involved in the intermediate tabulation which standards should be as high as that of the polling station staff. 2) Intermediate tabulation should be computerized taking in consideration that next elections will comprise more than three times the number of minutes of results “editais”.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Professionalism of the electoral administration, paragraph 5 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The preparation in advance of a comprehensive logistical plan for the elections and a contingency plan ready to face the possibility of extending the polling. Next elections
will cover the whole country to the most remote rural places.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Voters registration and voters lists, paragraph 1 (Voter registration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

To complete and correct the voters’ registration data from 1999 and 2003 in order to avoid even more errors when adding data from 2004 registration.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Voters registration and voters lists, paragraph 2 (Voter registration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Currently, there is one database in software MS Access for each province. This is neither sustainable nor efficient. The database should be unified. The centralized data base
should be fully operational latest May 2004.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Voters registration and voters lists, paragraph 3 (Voter registration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The up-date of voters registration for 2004 should be reorganized in such a way that the deficiencies experienced during 2003 up-date could be avoided, i.e. lack of material,
large number of human errors in recording data. STAE should start this work as soon as possible.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Voters registration and voters lists, paragraph 4 (Voter registration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The public and political parties should be allowed to check the electronic voters list before they are ready for distribution to the CDEs and polling stations.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 1 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

CNE should consider to maintain an open dialog with the political forces not represented in CNE and STAE and amend its working procedures in a way that allows election
participants and observers to follow the decision making process.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 2 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The electoral administration should give clear and timely information to the public on all the steps of the electoral process; this should include openness when failures or errors occur.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 3 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

To invite the political parties and observers to check samples of the sensitive election material and test the ink.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 4 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

To allow the presence of party delegates at the intermediate tabulation and of observers and party delegates at the sending procedures of intermediate results


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 5 (Civil Society and domestic Observation) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

To allow the presence of party delegates and observers at the sensitive procedure of requalification of votes. In Mozambican elections the invalid votes use to be in a
significant amount and can affect results.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 6 (Civil Society and domestic Observation) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

To allow the presence of delegates of political parties and observers at the tabulation process at the central level. Observers can not be limited to a focal room where they only can follow the input of votes in a screen. Credible observation is only possible by moving freely around the computer room as well as having the right to put questions to
the data technicians in order to follow up the process in line with international practice.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 7 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Full access for international observers should contribute to the building up of confidence in the Computer system. Sharing a copy of used software including its source code for
assessment purposes could be one way of showing transparency. If installed in a separate stand alone computer it could not harm the system or the database and would only build up public confidence.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 8 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Guarantee the free movement of observers in the whole country as established in the law by issuing accreditations with no geographical restriction


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 9 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Timely publication of complete and accurate results from polling station to national level.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Enhance transparency to increase credibility, paragraph 10 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The launching of a permanent Website by CNE where the electoral results, instructions and decisions could be published and accessible for the public would contribute to higher credibility in the electoral authorities and the electoral process as a whole


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Other recommendations 1 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The seal number used in the ballot boxes on Election Day was recorded on a mere notebook. Because it is a security measure the seal number should be recorded in the
polling station minute “Acta”.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Other recommendations 2 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

The serial number that every ballot slip has should be removed in order to maximize voter’s rights to secrecy. The number allows identifying who vote for whom and thus
violates the secrecy of voting in case where a recounting might be undertaken.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Other recommendations 3 (Parties and Candidates) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

In line with practice in many election systems it could be considered to lift the requirement for parties which had already contested in previous elections to gather
signatures in order to register as election participants.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Other recommendations 4 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2003
by: EU

Finally, and even though no particular problems were observed, it would be advisable to train the police officers about their role in the electoral contest, as it happened in 1994.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Recommendations on Further Action on the General Elections, paragraph 1 (Complaints and Appeals) Nigeria 2003
by: EU

Where petitions are filed by political parties or candidates Election Tribunals and the Appeal Courts shall carefully analyse the evidence provided and decide
without delay.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report