Recommendations —
English
 

Election Observation Portal - Recommendations Database

Country

Year

Topic

Organization

Recommendation status


Keywords (full text search)




691 recommendations
Recommendation 9 (Election Administration) Malawi 2009
by: EU

The political party consultative meetings should be developed as a more regular platform of dialogue between the Electoral Commission and the political parties. Full transparency measures need also to be introduced including formal rules for meetings and published minutes and consideration should be given to appointing a liaison officer for political parties and other stakeholders. Full financial transparency measures should also be introduced for the organisation of these meetings.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 10 (Election Administration) Malawi 2009
by: EU

The returning officers should be supported at constituency level by two deputy returning officers during periods of elections. Consideration should be made to strengthening the role and increasing the resources available for the district electoral clerks. Furthermore, provisions should be made for the pool of temporary polling staff including presiding officers be drawn from a wider group of candidates and appointed after public advertisement of these posts.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 11 (Election Administration) Malawi 2009
by: EU

The Electoral Commission should increase its training activities and design a permanent and rolling programme for polling officials to ensure all areas of the technical process are fully understood by officials. This should cover all election related processes ranging from voter registration and aggregation. Systems for communication from the Electoral Commission to the field need to be reviewed to ensure consistent and regular directions are communicated in a timely manner across the country.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 12 (Election Administration) Malawi 2009
by: EU

An adequate and reliable results system should be designed to ensure the integrity and reliability in the collection, aggregation and publication of results. Key procedures should be reviewed and suitable measures put in place to ensure the accuracy and security of results as they are collected from polling stations.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 13 (Election Administration) Malawi 2009
by: EU

A review of the electoral services and information technology departments of the Electoral Commission should be undertaken in respect to the system employed for the
collection of the final results. Adequate training for staff responsible in the field for aggregation of results should be provided and more resources available to enable them to carry out their work.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 27 (Election Administration) Malawi 2009
by: EU

More training conducted well in advance of election day should be planned by the Electoral Commission. A permanent register of polling officials should be maintained with regular training sessions conducted throughout the country. This training should include polling officials, party agents, observers and security forces. It should also clearly outline the roles and responsibilities of the different stakeholders in respect to the election process.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 6 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2009
by: EU

The composition of the CNE should be professionalised. Its members should be appointed by a platform constituted by civil society organisations.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 7 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2009
by: EU

The mandate of the members of CNE should be extended for more than five years so that experience in managing electoral processes is gained and lessons learnt pass from one process to another.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 8 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2009
by: EU

The Constitutional Council should have its mandate extended in order to supervise the performance of the National Electoral Commission and its respect for legal provisions that confer transparency to the process.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 9 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2009
by: EU

CNE should have clear responsibility for the work of all election officials and the duty to refer to the public prosecution office possible malpractices committed during election operations.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 10 (Election Administration) Mozambique 2009
by: EU

CNE should continue to take steps to improve the transparency of its operations at all levels. In particular, it should develop a communication strategy including the prompt and complete publication of all decisions and internal procedures and regular consultative meetings with political parties. This should include transparency and communication measures regarding its procurement procedures.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Essential Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) El Salvador 2009
by: EU

Essential - It would be recommendable to separate the TSE’s administrative and judicial functions.
Addressed to - Legislative Assembly.
Possible Improvements Suggested - The separation of the TSE’s administrative and judicial functions would enable greater efficiency in the organisation of electoral processes that could be under the responsibility of a professionalised and clearly executive directorate within the TSE and under the supervision of the TSE Magistrates. This would allow the magistrates to focus on taking judicial decisions, even against the TSE’s own administrative measures, as well as functions pertaining to the Court’s institutional representation. This would be, naturally more effective, within a TSE free from party interference.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) El Salvador 2009
by: EU

Essential - The nation-wide implementation of the residential vote would be desirable for the next elections.
Addressed to - TSE.
Possible Improvements Suggested - The TSE could extend the residential vote to the entire country for the 2012 elections. This would bring ballot boxes closer to voters, thus avoiding, or minimising, the need for the TSE to organise public transport for voters towards Polling Centres, or even worse to leave this transport in the hands of the political parties. This measure would also lead to the disappearance and/or relieve the overcrowding of the currently enormous Polling Centres in urban areas.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Essential Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) El Salvador 2009
by: EU

Essential - If the nation-wide implementation of the residential-vote were to be delayed, it would be recommendable that all free transportation of voters towards Polling Centres on Election Day be organised exclusively by the TSE.
Addressed to - TSE.
Possible Improvements Suggested - Political party organised transportation of voters towards Polling Centres creates conditions that are propitious to the inducement of voters during Election Day.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Essential Box (Direct Election to PARLACEN) (Election Administration) El Salvador 2009
by: EU

Essential - For future electoral processes, the introduction of a specific ballot paper for the election of PARLACEN parliamentarians would be a very positive measure.
Addressed to - Legislative Assembly.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Desirable Box (TSE Temporary Organs) (Election Administration) El Salvador 2009
by: EU

Desirable - If the residential vote were to be extended nation-wide, it would be desirable that JEDs and JEMs begin to operate earlier, with respect to Election Day, than in these previous elections.
Addressed to - Legislative Assembly and TSE.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Desirable Box (TSE Training) (Election Administration) El Salvador 2009
by: EU

Desirable - The EU EOM recommends that the TSE training of JRV members be strengthened for future elections. On the other hand, if the participation of political parties is reduced in the electoral administration, this should also put an end to political party participation in the training of JRV staff.
Addressed to - TSE.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 1 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

The BEC should undergo a review of its activities during the 2008 elections with a particular view to maintaining/increasing confidence in its activities. It should review the structure of its organization in order to strengthen and develop the capacity of its middle management and its secretariat. Consideration should be given to developing the field office structure of the BEC, so that permanent staff fulfil the lead role for elections, rather than local civil administration staff. A dedicated cadre of BEC staff falling under the responsibility of the Election Commission could be envisaged. In due course, appointment of Returning Officers and Assistant Returning Offices from among the senior ranks of such a cadre should be considered.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 2 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

The BEC should issue detailed regulations and procedures for the conduct of the entire election at every single stage and level of the process (i.e. polling centre, constituency level and national level) and provide for full transparency of BEC work at every level. Moreover, the BEC should (i) enforce the stipulation that result forms should be publicly displayed at every level of the election administration, and (ii) ensure that results are immediately published by polling centre at the constituency level and on the BEC website.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 3 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

In view of the total dysfunction of the postal ballot, the BEC is advised to remove it as a polling option for security agents, displaced electoral personnel, polling staff and persons in legal detention. The postal ballot should be replaced by other different voting options: the BEC is advised to facilitate the voting of all the Security agents by a special voting day for the security forces at least ten days prior to the scheduled Election Day; for polling staff the BEC is advised to facilitate the use of an additional or supplementary voter list in each PC/PB that would include all the electoral/polling staff present at the PC/PB so as to permit them to vote; for prisoners the BEC is advised toconsider holding elections inside the 67 prisons of the country by designating all prisons as ‘special polling centres’ for the elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 4 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

The BEC is advised to permit domestic observers to observe in their areas of registration and residence, so as to allow them to vote without lengthy travel to their respective Unions, which prevented them from exercising their right to vote in the December 2008 election. The current restrictions on the age for observers should be eliminated or at least be lowered to 21 years.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 5 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

The Voter List should be organised in alphabetical order at the PCs and PBs so as to facilitate the information to voters for them to know in which PB they should vote. A second copy of the VL should be available at the PC for voters to check by themselves or with the help of some BEC official which is their PB.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 6 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

In the case of a party nominating multiple candidates in a constituency, the BEC should, in fairness to all parties, insist that only one be retained prior to the scrutiny of nomination papers, in accordance with the RPO.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 21 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

BEC regulations should stipulate counting the voters’ signatures on the ballot paper counterfoils or counting the names ticked in the voter list and reconciling the resulting total with the number of ballot papers in the ballot boxes.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 22 (Election Administration) Bangladesh 2008
by: EU

In order to guarantee transparency legal and procedural stipulations should be enforced during the consolidation process, keeping totally separate the informative channel for provisional results and the official consolidation that provides final official results. All those involved in the consolidation process must be provided with clear, timely and transparent information on the time and place where consolidations take place.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Essential Recommendations Paragraph #1 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

The government of Cambodia must take credible steps to ensure that the NEC operates as a fully independent institution at all levels in order to enhance its credibility and acceptance among the electorate. Members of the NEC should be approved by a consensus among all political parties represented in the National Assembly. In particular the NEC chairperson should be a person acceptable to all political parties represented in the National Assembly. The limitation of the term in office of the chairperson and members of the NEC should be considered.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Essential Recommendations Paragraph #3 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

The use of the Form 1018 should be abolished prior to any future election.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Essential Recommendations Paragraph #5 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

The Village Chiefs should not be allowed to take a major part in the distribution of VINs. The NEC should find an alternative method of distribution that can take place with the presence of party agents and CEC members.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Desirable Recommendations Paragraph #7 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

"Definitions for some important terms (such as ""minor offence"", ""flagrant delicto"", ""affecting the election results"") should be included in the LEMNA and/or the Regulations and Procedures."


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Desirable Recommendations Paragraph #8 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

The tasks and responsibilities of the lower levels of the electoral administration, for example the role of CECs in consolidating the election results from the PS and their role in the Complaints and Appeals process, should be more clearly defined in the LEMNA rather than only in the NEC Regulations and Procedures.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Desirable Recommendations Paragraph #9 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

A legal obligation for the Election Commissions to closely cooperate with the court in case of election-related serious crimes should be established, in order to ensure that an investigation is conducted without delay.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Desirable Recommendations Paragraph #12 (Election Administration) Cambodia 2008
by: EU

The criteria for the appointment of the PECs and the CECs should be reconsidered. The appointment of experienced persons is justified, but without jeopardising the performance of the election administration, the employment of qualified persons without prior election experience should be considered.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 10 (Election Administration) Rwanda 2008
by: EU

Regulations and procedures issued by the NEC should be reviewed and where necessary clearer, more precise and more detailed provisions should be proposed. It should be ensured that NEC procedures are properly enforced.
a. The use of additional voter lists should be limited and a reconciliation system for persons voting outside of their original place of registration needs to be introduced.
b. Detailed procedures should clearly establish the sealing of ballot boxes and the use of the numbered seals before voting starts, after voting finishes and after counting is completed.
c. Detailed procedures should reinforce the use of indelible ink to avoid double voting.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 12 (Election Administration) Rwanda 2008
by: EU

The NEC should issue further guidelines to ensure the implementation of the reconciliation of ballot papers by enforcement of the existing law and procedures.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 14 (Election Administration) Rwanda 2008
by: EU

The National Electoral Commission is advised to put in place a numbering system for polling stations and polling centres.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Essential Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Essential - Strengthen the impartiality of the CNE.
Addressed to - Gov.
Possible Improvements Suggested - Nominate at least two new members from opposition parties.
Timeline - Next six months.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation First Desirable Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Desirable - Strengthen the powers of the CNE by ensuring that they have more direct support from different government departments that assist in the delivery of electoral support rather than having to rely on the CIPE to coordinate this support on their behalf.
Addressed to - National Assembly.
Possible Improvements Suggested - Set CNE budgets more accurately and in advance to ensure that funds arrive on time.
Timeline - By May 2009.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Second Essential Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Essential - Strengthen the structure of the CNE directorates to ensure more effective decision making and communication.
Addressed to - CNE.
Possible Improvements Suggested:
- Conduct more training for GMEs and CPEs.
- Give GMEs more responsibility for checking polling station results after the election and allow CPEs to tabulate provincial results in accordance with the law.
- Creation of an overall management post to facilitate communication and information sharing.
- Re-locate logistics section under the directorate of Organization (DOETTI).
- Devolve more decision making powers to the directorates.
- Recruit of new professional staff to fill identified gaps in the administration structure structure of the CNE directorates to ensure more effective decision making and communication.
Timeline - Over next year.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Second Desirable Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Desirable - Tasks & responsibilities of lower levels of electoral administration should be more clearly defined.
Addressed to - CNE.
Possible Improvements Suggested:
- Conduct more training for GMEs and CPEs.
- Give GMEs more responsibility for checking polling station results after the election and allow CPEs to tabulate provincial results in accordance with the law.
- Creation of an overall management post to facilitate communication and information sharing.
- Re-locate logistics section under the directorate of Organization (DOETTI)
- Devolve more decision making powers to the directorates.
- Recruit of new professional staff to fill identified gaps in the administration structure.
Timeline - Over next year.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Third Desirable Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Desirable - CPE and GMEs in Luanda to be strengthened to enable them to cope with the large number of Mesas de Voto they manage.
Addressed to - CNE.
Possible Improvements Suggested:
- Conduct more training for GMEs and CPEs.
- Give GMEs more responsibility for checking polling station results after the election and allow CPEs to tabulate provincial results in accordance with the law.
- Creation of an overall management post to facilitate communication and information sharing.
- Re-locate logistics section under the directorate of Organization (DOETTI)
- Devolve more decision making powers to the directorates.
- Recruit of new professional staff to fill identified gaps in the administration structure.
Timeline - Over next year.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Fourth Desirable Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Desirable - Ensure that there is a timetable for decision making and that this is adhered to.
Addressed to - CNE.
Possible Improvements Suggested:
- Conduct more training for GMEs and CPEs.
- Give GMEs more responsibility for checking polling station results after the election and allow CPEs to tabulate provincial results in accordance with the law.
- Creation of an overall management post to facilitate communication and information sharing.
- Re-locate logistics section under the directorate of Organization (DOETTI)
- Devolve more decision making powers to the directorates.
- Recruit of new professional staff to fill identified gaps in the administration structure.
Timeline - Over next year.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Third Essential Bullet-point (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Essential - Improve the transparency of the CNEs operations and decisions, especially in allowing party agents and observers in to the National Counting centre to monitor the tabulation of the results and publishing the results desegregated by polling station.
Addressed to - CNE.
Possible Improvements Suggested:
- Make CNE formal decision making sessions open to domestic and international observers as well as to party agents.
- Information on decisions should be permanently available on the web site and posted more rapidly.
- Posting the election results by polling station on the CNE web site to facilitate verification by political contestants.
- Make space available for party agents (mandatários) to be present and able to monitor all aspects of post election handling of materials and results at GMEs, CPEs and most importantly at he national counting centre (Centro de Escrutinio) to ensure full confidence in the results.
- The accreditation process for observers and party agents (delegados das listas) should be improved to ensure equal and timely treatment.
Timeline - Over next year.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Second Desirable Bullet-point (Election Material) (Election Administration) Angola 2008
by: EU

Desirable - Ensure all materials are delivered the day before and include lamps. Ensure adequate transport for Presidents of each Polling station to the GME to answer questions in case of problems.
Addressed to - CNE.
Possible Improvements Suggested:
- Between 700 and 1000 voters per polling station in urban areas is a guideline but may be less in rural areas.
- Polling stations should be located in schools and public buildings where possible, rather than in tents, to enable people to locate their polling stations more easily, provide an area for posting the results, give a more orderly environment for voting and access to electricity for the counting.
Timeline - Procedures should all be determined at least three months prior to next elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 8 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

The international community should consider providing study visits for ECB staff on particular technical issues of interest (e.g. campaign finance, voter registration, voter education, comparative electoral systems, boundary delimitation, etc).


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 9 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

A Legal Department should be established within the ECB to enhance its capacity to consider legal reforms and to deal with legal issues that arise.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 10 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

The EDSB should make all decisions on complaints accessible to the public, for instance through the Internet.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 11 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

The ECB should consider meeting in formal, scheduled sessions that could be observed by party representatives, international and domestic observers, and the media. This would increase the necessary transparency of the Electoral Administration.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 12 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

The ECB should expand and improve its website so that it has the capacity to make all notifications, announcements and decisions available to the public. The website acts as a key instrument for ensuring transparency of the ECB.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 13 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

National Observers should be renamed “Election Supervisors” and new regulations for their activities should be drafted to distinguish their role from that of independent observers.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 14 (Election Administration) Bhutan 2008
by: EU

The ECB should ensure that Returning Officers are adequately resourced, including convenient access to high-speed Internet facilities where possible.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report