Delimiting electoral district boundaries can have major consequences for the voters, political groups and communities of interest residing within these constituencies as well as for the representatives elected to serve these constituencies. Ultimately, the election outcome and the political composition of the legislature may be affected by the constituency boundaries. A failure to recognize the importance of the electoral boundary delimitation process and its impact can have serious ramifications: If stakeholders suspect that electoral boundaries have been unfairly manipulated – benefiting some groups at the expense of others – this will affect the credibility and the legitimacy of the election process and its outcome.
In this module we explore the potential consequences of drawing – or not drawing – electoral boundaries and identify the principles that lead to a fair and effective delimitation process if electoral district boundaries are to be created. Participants examine alternatives for structuring the boundary authority and rules for carrying out the process. In addition, participants engage in a number of activities designed to familiarize them with the tasks involved in delimiting electoral boundaries.
Countries that delimit districts must establish a structure and a set of rules for carrying out the process. This module introduces participants to a wide variety of options by comparing and contrasting the delimitation practices of numerous countries and considering the potential consequences of adopting these differing approaches, encouraging participants to evaluate which methods are potentially sustainable in their own context. The subjects covered in this component of the module include:
- Boundary Authority: Who will draw the constituency boundaries? What are the functions of this body and the skills needed to be successful? Is the legislature to have any role in the process? If not, who will have the authority for selecting the final constituency plan? Should the constituency boundaries be subject to challenge (for example, in a court of law)?
- Delimitation Trigger(s): What prompts a delimitation exercise? Is there an established time frame (e.g., delimitation must occur every ten years), or does delimitation follow a national census, or perhaps it must be conducted prior to every parliamentary election?
-
Public Access to the Delimitation Process: Should some mechanism exist for public input into to the delimitation process? If so, how should this mechanism be structured?
-
Establishment of Delimitation Criteria: What criteria should the boundary authority take into account when delimiting constituency boundaries? At a minimum, constituencies should be as equal in population as practicable. Other criteria the boundary authority might be obliged to take into account include geographic features, compactness and contiguity, communities of interest, and protection for special minority groups.
Key Understandings
- To explore alternative approaches to Boundary Delimitation
- To introduce the main principles underlying a credible and acceptable boundary delimitation process
- To experience delimitation tasks such as allocating seats, producing databases of maps and data, evaluating district plans and preparing an operational plan for the conduct of a delimitation process
|
Module Objectives
- Electoral representation can be affected by a number of factors. Boundary delimitation is one possible factor.
- Boundary Delimitation has an effect upon the political process as a whole.
- Clear and accepted guiding principles for Boundary Delimitation help provide legitimacy to the process.
- Policy choices based on clear criteria are necessary to achieve legitimacy in the Boundary Delimitation process.
- The Boundary Delimitation Authority should meet the needs of the stakeholders in the process
- An effectively structured Boundary Delimitation Authority can provide legitimacy to the Boundary Delimitation process.
- Providing public access in the form of a consultation process promotes transparency and legitimacy. In addition, voters and other stakeholders who object to the electoral boundaries created should have an opportunity to have their objections heard.
- Boundary Delimitation process should be based in good, enforceable law.
- The feasibility of particular approaches to Boundary Delimitation will be dependent on the resources and data available.
- Boundary Delimitation involves performing a range of potentially complex tasks.
- A comprehensive plan and budget are key elements in Boundary Delimitation.
|
|
|
Boundary Delimitation Module |
Module Outline
- Key Understandings
- Introduction to Boundary Delimitation
- Structure of the Boundary Delimiting Body
- Rules for Delimiting Electoral Boundaries
- Tasks Involved in the Boundary Delimitation Process
- Operational Planning for Boundary Delimitation
- Make it Happen
|