| 3752 recommendations |
Recommendation 37 (Detection and Mitigation of Fraud) Afghanistan 2009
by: EU
Fraud detection measures should include the following considerations: - Reconciliation forms and the lists of voters are good instruments for the mitigation of fraud as they can be used to detect excess numbers of ballots. Although both were available in the 2009 elections, there was no incentive for their appropriate completion as they were not subsequently used to cross-check the number of voters with the number of ballots cast. Cross-checking of reconciliation forms and lists of voters should be mandatory for future elections. - Clear and binding procedures for auditing should be in place at the beginning of the electoral process, to avoid last-minute improvisations that are not generally understood by the public. Auditing is just a more precise and targeted way of counting and as such should be in the public domain and conducted in a manner which is transparent and understandable for voters. - The final number and locations of polling centres and polling stations should be publicised at the beginning of the electoral process. Any kind of changes in numbers or locations should be fully justified and publicised immediately. This would safeguard against the risk of fraud though ballot stuffing, using electoral materials earmarked for polling stations which never opened to establish ghost polling stations. - Clear and binding procedures should be in place to ensure efficient tracking of all unused electoral material. In order to prevent excess electoral materials being distributed to the provinces and used to commit fraud, only officially listed polling stations should receive electoral material.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Legal Framework) (Legal Framework) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - A law on Referenda or a comprehensive chapter on the matter should be introduced in the new election law. This should include specificities of referenda processes. Addressed to: 1. National Assembly. 2. NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - The new law should endeavor to include: - Provision on equal financial and broadcasting support to political parties. - The principle of equality of opportunity should be guaranteed. - Clarify the role of the State in taking part in providing voter information. - Provisions for the authorities to provide objective information. - Provisions on the questions in order to respect the unity of form, of content, of hierarchical level. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least one year before the next referendum.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Legal Framework) (Legal Framework) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - The law should provide for independent candidates to run for elections. Addressed to - National Assembly. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment to the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least two years before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - NEC should be able to apply administrative sanctions such as fines and suspension of illegal publicity. This would considerably increase efficiency and celerity. Addressed to - National Assembly. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment to the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least two years before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Clear procedures for nomination and appointment of electoral delegates, provincial board members based on merit and experience. Addressed to - NEC Possible Improvements Suggested - Elaboration of Regulations to the Electoral Law establishing qualifications and procedures for electoral delegates and provincial board members and applying the Law on Public Service for the rest of election staff. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - Following the appointment of the new NEC.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Essential Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Clear and transparent information policy about tabulation, inconsistencies and recounting process, both on PEB and on NEC level (website). Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - NEC could have an adequate professional press room as well as more manpower in order to enhance transparency through a more proactive dialogue with electoral stakeholders. - A closer synergy between the departments of Communication, Electoral Promotion and Civic Education could optimize information strategy. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Election Administration) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desireable - NEC should improve the level of institutional communication with the general public, media and political organisations in order to avoid controversies and miss information and strengthen public trust on a long term basis. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - NEC could have an adequate professional press room as well as more manpower in order to enhance transparency through a more proactive dialogue with electoral stakeholders. - A closer synergy between the departments of Communication, Electoral Promotion and Civic Education could optimize information strategy. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box, Top Paragraph (Election Preparation) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Polling station members should be selected one month before e-day. Addressed to - NEC. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box, Bottom Paragraph (Election Preparation) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Implementation of effective procedures to communicate appointments to the polling station committee members. Addressed to - NEC. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Election Preparation) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Appropriate and timely training to all election staff. Training to Polling station members should emphasize on accurate completion of the results protocols and the determination of the validity of the ballots. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Establishment of a permanent pool of electoral trainers. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Election Preparation) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Specific training for polling centres Coordinators on E-day procedures and transmission of results to the next level should be foreseen for the next electoral cycle. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Improve the selection of polling centre Coordinators based on their qualification. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Essential Box (Election Preparation) (Electoral System) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - The number of members of the National Assembly per constituency should be determined taking into account the number of registered voters (as the relevant electoral part of the population) and be regularly updated in order to give all electors balanced voting powers in line with international standards. Addressed to: 1. National Assembly. 2. NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested: 1. Amendment to the Election Law. 2. Regular update by NEC resolution three to six months before the election. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline: 1. At least two years before the next electoral cycle. 2. In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Voter Registration) (Voter Registration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Establishment of a detailed calendar for the verification/update/information period of the voter register by electors well in advance of Election Day. This would allow voters to make addition and changes after the official call for the elections. After the verification period the new NEC should undertake the necessary corrections and display the voter register again at cantonal or parish levels at least 15 days prior to Election Day. Addressed to - National Assembly; NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment to the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least two years before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Voter Registration) (Voter Registration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - The Civil Registry should be improved to ensure all citizens are registered and provided with ID Cards. Addressed to: 1. Civil Registry. 2. Army. Possible Improvements Suggested: 1. More mobile teams should be used to register Ecuadorians living in remote and less accessible areas especially in the Amazonian region and in the Northern part of Esmeraldas. 2. More accurate information should be provided regarding where the army personnel will be stationed during E-day. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Civic & Voter Education) (Voter Education) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Voter education campaign should be implemented sooner. An increased degree of outsourcing or network with public institutions and civil society organizations could enhance the process. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - According to international standards, voter education campaigns are necessary to ensure the effective exercise by an informed community on their electoral rights. A best international practice is to undertake widespread voter education campaigns with the support of government and civil society. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer public information and civic education expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities, or support local NGOs involved in these activities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Civic & Voter Education) (Voter Education) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - NGOs and Government Institutions during the entire campaign period should increase their efforts to promote voter information and civic education features, both in Ecuador and in host countries with important Ecuadorian diaspora (OCV). Addressed to: 1. NGOs. 2. Government institutions. Possible Improvements Suggested: 1. Elaborate a well planned action plan, involving more local NGOs and associations, adapt local action plans with PEBs according to regional necessities, diversify communication tools, use indigenous languages, optimize timeline of voter education campaign for the young (16 – 18) according to school holidays in order to increase outreach. 2. Out-of-country voting: Give more importance and emphasis to out-of - country electorate and their information needs. Encourage participation by informing them that their participation will have no consequence on their status in host country. (Confidentiality of personal data). EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer public information and civic education expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities, or support local NGO’s involved in these activities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Desirable Box (Civic & Voter Education) (Voter Education) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Voter education should include information about the complex election procedures and the weight of their vote in terms of seat allocation. Addressed to - NEC. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer public information and civic education expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities or support local NGOs involved in these activities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Campaign Environment/Financing) (Campaign Environment) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Exit polls and quick counts should be clearly regulated by law in order to strengthen its legal basis. By doing so, arbitrary measures taken on the matter by then election administration could be avoided. Addressed to - National Assembly; NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment to the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least two years before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Campaign Environment/Financing) (Campaign Environment) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - In line with the provisions of the 2008 Constitution (article 115) and the 2009 Election Law (article 207) that forbid state institutions to advertise for electoral campaigning, it would be advisable that the Election Law would define exactly what is considered campaigning during an electoral period. Addressed to - National Assembly; NEC; EDT. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment to the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least two years before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Essential Box (Campaign Environment/Financing) (Campaign Environment) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Legislation on the campaign, especially those preventing the abuse of office, should be strictly enforced and the pertinent authorities should apply adequate sanctions against violators. Addressed to - NEC; EDT. Possible Improvements Suggested - This should include the development and implementation of more effective measures for monitoring and dealing with abuse of public resources. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Fourth Essential Box (Campaign Environment/Financing) (Campaign Environment) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - A clear distinction must be drawn between the state and its activities on one hand, and the election contenders and their campaign on the other. This distinction must be fully observed in the conduct of the campaign in order to avoid the violation of equality of opportunities among the contestants. Addressed to - Incumbent Candidates. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Campaign Environment/Financing) (Campaign Environment) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Whilst being so short, electoral promotion tv spots all ended with large NEC corporate logo, which monopolized the spectator’s final attention. NEC identification in electoral promotion should be present, but less dominant in order to draw attention to the candidate or party. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Fifth Essential Box (Campaign Environment/Financing) (Campaign Environment) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - The NEC should ensure from the beginning of the campaign sufficient use of free airtime among candidates to allow them to accurately communicate their political program to the electorate. The innovation of the new franjas electorales could be enlarged to cover all the campaign period. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - NEC regulations. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Political Parties) (Parties and Candidates) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - The information provided by political parties and movements to the Election Administration about their campaign expenditure should be made public. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Political Parties) (Parties and Candidates) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Political parties should develop their internal capacity and structures to stimulate the establishment of their political platforms. Addressed to - Political Subjects. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Desirable Box (Political Parties) (Parties and Candidates) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Parties and Candidates’ agents should receive training in key legal aspects of the election such as how to file complaints properly. Addressed to - Political Subjects. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Women) (Women) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Voter education campaigns targeting especially rural and illiterate women should be conducted. Addressed to - NEC. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer finance to NGOs . Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Desirable Box (Women) (Women) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Training/ capacity building of women’s candidates should be increased. Addressed to - NEC. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer finance to NGOs . Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Desirable Box (Women) (Women) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - More efforts should be made to address women’s rights and issues as campaign topics. Addressed to - Political Subjects. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Fourth Desirable Box (Women) (Women) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - More efforts should be made to include more women in the lower levels of election administration. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Indigenous and Afroecuadorian) (Minorities) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - More efforts should be made to address indigenous and afro- Ecuadorian’s rights and issues as campaign topics. Addressed to - Political Subjects. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Desirable Box (Indigenous and Afroecuadorian) (Minorities) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - More efforts should be made to include more indigenous and afro-Ecuadorians in the lower levels of election administration. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Indigenous and Afroecuadorian) (Minorities) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Voter education campaign should be conducted in indigenous languages, and adapt to local necessities in order to reach rural and minority population. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - For this purpose increased cooperation with institutions such as CODENPE and NGOs would be recommendable. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer finance to NGOs. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Media) (Media) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Ecuador’s different media outlets should make efforts to be impartial in their coverage during campaign, abiding by professional standards, avoiding biased reporting and assuring pluralistic and open debate. Addressed to - Media. Possible Improvements Suggested - During election campaign all media outlets should be more active in organizing special election programs such as face to face debates and panel discussion with candidates. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Media) (Media) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - A new law should regulate the new State-owned media in order to ensure a strict impartial coverage of electoral campaign and equal access to all candidates refraining from giving any unfair advantage to the incumbent. Furthermore new instruments should be introduced setting out the mandate and responsibilities of state owned broadcasters, and their independence from the authorities. Addressed to - National Assembly. Possible Improvements Suggested - To harmonize the new constitutional prohibition of all forms of privately financed publicity in electoral campaigns with the respect of freedom of expression. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - Wishfully in one-year time, in the framework of the implementation of the new 2008 Constitution.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Essential Box (Media) (Media) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - The Radio and Television Law should be amended in order to regulate the use of “cadenas nacionales” clarifying their purpose and setting the limits of time and frequency for all the authorities. During the election period limits should be set to avoid its use for institutional propaganda. Addressed to - National Assembly. Possible Improvements Suggested - Revision of Radio and Television Law and revocation of the current law on “cadenas nacionales” that still dates from the dictatorship era. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - Wishfully in one-year time, in the framework of the implementation of the new 2008 Constitution.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Polling) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Allow polling station committee members and election co- ordinators to vote in the polling station they work in. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - NEC regulation. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Essential Box (Polling) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Results should be displayed outside of the polling centres. Addressed to - National Assembly; NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment to the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least two years before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Essential Box (Polling) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Make polling stations accessible to remote and isolated areas. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - For this purpose increased cooperation with government institutions (CODENPE) and NGOs would be recommendable. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Fourth Essential Box (Polling) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Facilitate the access to polling stations to handicapped citizens. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - The provisions of ground floor stations, where possible, and facilitate transportation for disabled voters, the infirm, elderly and pregnant women. Support civil society initiatives ie. Taxi Solidario in order to reach all provinces. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Polling) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Political subjects should make an additional effort to appoint agents to oversee the election process. These agents should receive proper training in order to fully understand their role in the process. Addressed to - Political Subjects. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Desirable Box (Polling) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - CNE should develop more efficient means to pay the members of the polling stations committees. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - For example making the payment available on polling day. If Polling Station members are provided a per diem, those who have to travel distances or those who have other responsibilities will be provided a greater motivation to attend training sessions and carry out their duties on election day. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Fifth Essential Box (Polling) (Election Administration) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Less number of polling stations except when serving remote or isolated populations. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - In this regard, the minimum number of electors per polling station should be increased to 400 or, if deemed feasible, to 500. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Third Desirable Box (Polling) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - The layout of the polling station should ensure the secrecy of vote. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Fourth Desirable Box (Polling) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Electors in the queue should be allowed to vote after the closing of the votes. Addressed to - National Assembly; NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Amendment of the Election Law. EC Support/Projects - EC should be ready to offer legal and electoral expertise if requested by Ecuadorian authorities. Timeline - At least one year before the next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Sixth Essential Box (Polling) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - Previously trained polling station committee members substitutes should not be released from their obligations if there is no need for a replacement during the opening of the polling. On the contrary, they can be used as fresh staff during the counting. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Counting) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - To better define the role of members of Polling Stations. At least two members should be involved in the process of counting the ballots, while at least two members should fill in each of the tally sheets. Addressed to - NEC. Possible Improvements Suggested - Appointment of dedicated polling station staff for counting and filling in of the election protocols could be an option. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation Second Desirable Box (Counting) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - To provide with clear and non-ambiguous instructions on what constitutes a valid vote and a null vote. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Essential Box (Tabulation and Announcement of Results) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Essential - NEC should enhance the accessibility and transparency of the recounting and tabulation process through an orderly and transparent workflow, easy to observe for party agents. Possible Improvements Suggested - Standardized webcams, observing rooms, Web TV screens can help. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|
Recommendation First Desirable Box (Tabulation and Announcement of Results) (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Ecuador 2009
by: EU
Desirable - Avoid the use of minors and other vulnerable groups in sensitive procedures such as recounts. Addressed to - NEC. Timeline - In time for next electoral cycle.
Recommendation status: recommended
Open full report
|