Recommendations —
English
 

Election Observation Portal - Recommendations Database

Country

Year

Topic

Organization

Recommendation status


Keywords (full text search)




3752 recommendations
Recommendation Media, paragraph 4 (Media) Malawi 2004
by: EU

A full licence should be issued to TVM.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 5 (Media) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Action against the media should only be taken by the licensing authority and MACRA, and not by the police.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 6 (Media) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Political debate and discussion programmes should be increased, particularly during the campaign period.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Media, paragraph 7 (Media) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Composition of management boards of MBC and TVM should ensure the confidence of election stakeholders.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Stakeholders, paragraph 1 (Election Administration) Malawi 2004
by: EU

National Elections Consultative Forum (NECOF) meetings should be held on a regular basis during the pre-election period and recommendations emerging from the meetings
properly implemented.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Stakeholders, paragraph 2 (Parties and Candidates) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Multi-Party Liaison Committee meetings should be held more regularly in the lead up to elections, and should include the participation of independent candidates.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Political Parties, paragraph 1 (Parties and Candidates) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Political parties should be required to declare their funding sources and how funds have been used. There should also be maximum limits for funding, donations received and funding expenditures.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Political Parties, paragraph 2 (Parties and Candidates) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Training should be provided for Parties and Candidates in a number of areas including (i) policy development, (ii) manifesto preparation, (iii) communication with
voters, (iv) the role and rights of monitors (for example, on complaint mechanisms).


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Civil Society, paragraph 1 (Civil Society and domestic Observation) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Training and support should be provided to civil society to strengthen capacity to conduct civic and voter education and election observation, including parallel vote
tabulation.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Civil Society, paragraph 2 (Civil Society and domestic Observation) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Sufficient resources should be provided to enable civil society to conduct civic and voter education and election observation in a comprehensive manner.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Participation of Women, paragraph 1 (Women) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Political parties should make serious efforts to (i) ensure that women are represented in senior positions, and (ii) select more women candidates in order to reach the SADC
target of 30% female representation in parliament.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Participation of Women, paragraph 2 (Women) Malawi 2004
by: EU

The MEC should take steps to increase the representation of women in all levels of the election administration.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Police, paragraph 1 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Malawi 2004
by: EU

Police should be properly trained on the role they should play on election day, specifically that they should not perform the tasks of polling officials.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 1 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The current level of educational requirements for candidates excludes a large portion of the population and effectively discriminates against women and indigenous minorities. No education requirements should be necessary to be a candidate for Regency/City DPRD Elections and consideration should be given to lowering them for other non- Presidential Elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 2 (Measures to sustain Emerging Democracy/Human Rights) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The right to stand should be immediately extended to former members of the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI) and related organisations for all elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 3 (Legal Framework) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Health requirements for presidential candidates should be abolished. However, the health status of candidates should be independently assessed and made public.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 4 (Legal Framework) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The restrictive requirements for the registration of political parties set forth in Law 31/2002 on Political Parties should be significantly lowered.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 5 (Parties and Candidates) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The requirements for political parties to participate in future Legislative Elections should be lowered. All parties should be allowed to stand again in the electoral districts where they have won seats in previous elections. At a minimum, consideration should also be given to maintaining the thresholds applied for the 2004 elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 6 (Electoral System) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The current threshold set for the direct elections of candidates under the Open List system should be lowered. Provisions should be introduced to enable the highest scoring
candidates in a given electoral district to be elected.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 7 (Electoral System) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The envisaged threshold of 15% of the DPR seats or the 20% of the DPR valid votes as a requirement for the nomination of candidate pairs in future Presidential Elections is too high. Consideration should be given to either keeping it at the present level or increasing it to a maximum of 5%.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 8 (Legal Framework) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Guidelines and regulations on the obligations and rights of presidential incumbents during electoral campaigns should be further strengthened. Consideration should be
given to introducing similar regulations for other incumbents at lower levels.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 9 (Election Administration) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

For the second round of Presidential Elections, provisions for a full campaign period should be enacted.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 10 (Campaign environment) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Regulations on party and candidate finances should be introduced. An effective investigative and auditing mechanism to review party and candidate donations and
campaign expenditure should be implemented. Effective and proportionate sanctions for violations of financial provisions should be enacted, and thresholds on campaign
expenditure should be set.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 11 (Complaints and Appeals) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The mechanisms for adjudicating electoral violations and election-related complaints should be revised. Election stakeholders should be granted the right to appeal KPU
decisions


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 12 (Complaints and Appeals) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

An independent judicial body, ideally within the existing judicial structure, should be mandated to adjudicate such cases. Alternatively, consideration should be given to the
creation of “ad hoc” election tribunal.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 13 (Legal Framework) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The existing electoral laws should be revised in order to remove inconsistencies, ambiguities and repetitions. Preferably, the different election laws should be unified in a
single electoral code containing both general provisions and separate chapters for each level of election.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 14 (Legal Framework) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The KPU regulations should be compiled into a single comprehensive text for future elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 15 (Election Administration) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The current electoral calendar should be reorganised for logistical reasons and in the light of the anticipated elections for Heads of Provinces and Regency/Cities. Preferably,
consideration should be given to staggering the elections with a two-year interval. One possibility could be to schedule National Legislative and Presidential Elections in one year and all other lower level elections in a different year. Alternatively, the elections could be staggered by dividing them between Legislative ones and Presidential/Heads of Provinces and Regency/City Elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 16 (Voter Registration) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Immediate steps should be taken to implement a permanent and centralised voter register. The maintenance of the voter register should not be devolved to the provincial
KPU, but remain under the control of the central KPU.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 17 (Election Administration) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

National elections should be funded exclusively by the central state budget.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 18 (Election Administration) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Adequate attention should be paid to the establishment within the KPU of a department for the training and professional development of election officials at all levels.
Supervisory mechanisms to monitor and review staff performance and alleged malpractice should be put in place, as well as to ensure the enforcement of the KPU’s
binding authority over its lower tiers


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 19 (Voter Education) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Proper attention should be paid to voter education in planning future electoral budgets. Priority should be given to concerted and longer-term efforts with larger involvement of grass-roots local organisations.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 20 (Election Administration) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Apart from the essential task of safeguarding the integrity and consistency of the election process, Provincial KPUs should be given responsibility for the implementation of the elections at their own level and below.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 21 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Ballot paper design should be made simpler and more user-friendly. Serial numbering and security features should be introduced at least for national election ballots.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 22 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Procedures should be designed to improve and expedite the manual aggregation of results and their publication. Efforts should be continued and enhanced to develop
programmes for the electronic tabulation of results.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 23 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The overall number of polling stations should be reduced by increasing the number of voters per polling stations. A national average of 600 voters per polling station would be
ideal, where feasible.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 24 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Uniform procedures for ensuring payment of polling station officials should be enacted.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 25 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Posting of election results at all levels should be enforced.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 26 (Polling, Counting and Publication of Results) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Polling stations should only be established in places accessible to the general public and where the KPU can exercise its authority.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 27 (Media) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The Indonesian Broadcasting Commission (KPI) should have the authority and the means to effectively regulate electronic media activity during elections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 28 (Media) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

The state broadcast media must be impartial and unbiased during the election period
and remain free from political interference.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 29 (Media) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Provisions should be established for a standard amount of free time to be allocated to parties and presidential candidate pairs by state and commercial broadcast media duringelections.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation 30 (Media) Indonesia 2004
by: EU

Media should provide free slots for voter education during prime time.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 1 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

"The wide variety of norms of different levels and nature (Law, Regulations, Codes of Conduct, Directives, Instructions, etc.) sometimes creates confusion as to which rule
should prevail. Some Directives adopted by the NEC, in particular the one related to campaign activities and the one on the ""quick action"" procedure should be incorporated in
the Law."


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 2 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The Electoral Law's provisions on the statute of election officials should clearly state their obligation to enforce the Law, even when no complaint is lodged. This additional
responsibility should be accompanied by deeper training sessions at CEC and PEC levels on litigation procedures.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 3 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The division of responsibilities between the NEC and the Courts with regards to dealing with cases of a penal nature but politically connected should be clarified. Eventually,
when sufficient trust in the judiciary will exist in Cambodia, the Courts should be fully in charge of penal offences related to the elections, the NEC only remaining in charge of
implementing the administrative part of the judgements, e.g. removal from voter list.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 4 (Complaints and Appeals) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

Offenders condemned by the NEC to penalties pursuant to art.124 and Chapter 11 of the Regulations and Procedures should be offered the possibility of appealing to either the Supreme Court or the Constitutional Council.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 5 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

As the Law on Commune Administration foresees that the Ministry of Interior should issue an act specifying how Village Chiefs should be selected, one should use this
opportunity to better regulate their role and responsibilities, inter alia during election processes.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 6 (Detection and Mitigation of Fraud) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

As distributions of gifts and incentives seem to be a widespread and deeply rooted political habit in Cambodia, a prohibition of distribution of incentives does not seem to be a workable option. For future elections, two directions should therefore be explored: a clear definition of what constitutes vote buying as well as a system of control of the
amounts distributed and of the modalities of distributions.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report
Recommendation Legal, paragraph 7 (Legal Framework) Cambodia 2003
by: EU

The Election Law should be amended to define the role of “alternate candidates” clearing their position and when and under which circumstances they replace outgoing members ofthe National Assembly.


Recommendation status: recommended

Open full report